Not Your Average Joes vs Ulta Birthday Rewards
Side-by-side comparison of the Not Your Average Joes and Ulta birthday programs, signup effort, offer count, and what you actually get.
The verdict: Not Your Average Joes vs Ulta
Not Your Average Joes vs Ulta: Ulta currently has more tracked birthday offers (3 vs 1). Both Not Your Average Joes and Ulta run a birthday reward through their loyalty programs, so the deciding factors are the type of offer, the signup effort, and how long you have to redeem. The good news. You don't have to choose: both programs are free and independent, so you can sign up for each and claim a birthday reward from both.
Side-by-side comparison
| Feature | Not Your Average Joes | Ulta |
|---|---|---|
| Tracked birthday deals | 1 | 3 |
| Primary category | birthday | birthday |
| Deal types | deal | freebie |
| Best for | birthday lovers | birthday lovers |
| Requires rewards signup | Yes | Yes |
| Typical window | Birthday month | Birthday month |
| Recommended signup lead time | 7-14 days | 7-14 days |
FAQs, Not Your Average Joes vs Ulta
How do the Not Your Average Joes and Ulta birthday programs compare?
Not Your Average Joes has 1 tracked birthday offer; Ulta has 3. Which one fits depends on the redemption window, signup requirements, and the type of offer, see the side-by-side table above for the breakdown.
Can I claim the birthday offer from both Not Your Average Joes and Ulta?
Yes, rewards programs are completely independent. Sign up for both, stack the offers, and claim one from each during your birthday month. Birthday Hunter tracks both and sends separate reminders for each.
Do I need separate accounts for Not Your Average Joes and Ulta rewards?
Yes, each brand requires its own rewards account. Sign up on each brand's website or app at least 1-2 weeks before your birthday. Birthday Hunter can auto-remind you which sign-ups are still pending.
Which is better for birthday rewards, Not Your Average Joes or Ulta?
Ulta currently has more tracked birthday offers (3 vs 1), but "better" depends on what you want to redeem. Since both are free, the best value is signing up for both.
Are Not Your Average Joes and Ulta birthday rewards free?
Yes. Joining either program is free and the birthday reward is a complimentary member perk. There's no purchase required to sign up, and Birthday Hunter is free to track both in one place.
Do not choose one. Stack both.
Not Your Average Joes and Ulta use separate loyalty programs, so the highest-value move is saving both rewards and claiming each during its own birthday window.
Last verified: October 2026